Cart 0

No more products available for purchase

Products
Add order notes
Subtotal
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout
  • American Express
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

Your Cart is Empty
Alternative Gemstone Engagement Rings - Penwarden Fine Jewellery

Explore our collection

Alternative Gemstone Engagement Rings

Sometimes diamonds aren’t a gal’s best friend! Our collection of alternative engagement rings feature colorful and unique gemstones.

Each ring is handmade by Linda's team of Master Goldsmiths in our on-site studio. If a style is listed as sold, it can be custom made especially for you.  

Our bridal loyalty program offers you 10% off wedding bands and all wedding jewellery with the purchase of any engagement ring! Ask us for details.  


3 CARAT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS
 
3 CARAT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS
3 CARAT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS
3 CARAT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS

3 CARAT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN PLATINUM

$5,535.00
ÉTOILE BLUE ZIRCON & DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
 
ÉTOILE BLUE ZIRCON & DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
ÉTOILE BLUE ZIRCON & DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
Sold Out - Request to Order

ÉTOILE BLUE ZIRCON & DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RING

$4,758.00
MIDNIGHT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL RINGS
 
MIDNIGHT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL RINGS
MIDNIGHT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL RINGS
MIDNIGHT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL RINGS
Sold Out - Request to Order

MIDNIGHT BLUE SAPPHIRE RING IN 18 KARAT GOLD

$4,685.00
TEAL SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING IN PLATINUM & 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
 
TEAL SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING IN PLATINUM & 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
TEAL SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING IN PLATINUM & 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS

TEAL SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING IN PLATINUM & 18 KARAT GOLD

$4,075.00
MONTANA BLUE SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING WITH TEARDROP CLAWS - ALL RINGS
 
MONTANA BLUE SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING WITH TEARDROP CLAWS - ALL RINGS
MONTANA BLUE SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING WITH TEARDROP CLAWS - ALL RINGS
Sold Out - Request to Order

MONTANA BLUE SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING WITH TEARDROP CLAWS

$4,550.00
5 CARAT YELLOW SAPPHIRE RING IN 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL RINGS
 
5 CARAT YELLOW SAPPHIRE RING IN 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL RINGS
5 CARAT YELLOW SAPPHIRE RING IN 18 KARAT GOLD - ALL RINGS

5 CARAT YELLOW SAPPHIRE RING IN 18 KARAT GOLD

$10,400.00
OLIVIA PINK SAPPHIRE & DIAMOND RING - ALL RINGS
 
OLIVIA PINK SAPPHIRE & DIAMOND RING - ALL RINGS
OLIVIA PINK SAPPHIRE & DIAMOND RING - ALL RINGS

OLIVIA PINK SAPPHIRE & DIAMOND RING

$5,715.00
BEA RING WITH ROUND ROSE CUT YELLOW SAPPHIRE AND DIAMONDS - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
 
BEA RING WITH ROUND ROSE CUT YELLOW SAPPHIRE AND DIAMONDS - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
BEA RING WITH ROUND ROSE CUT YELLOW SAPPHIRE AND DIAMONDS - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS

BEA RING WITH ROUND ROSE CUT YELLOW SAPPHIRE AND DIAMONDS

$3,070.00
BEA RING WITH ROSE CUT PURPLE SAPPHIRE AND DIAMONDS - ALL RINGS
 
BEA RING WITH ROSE CUT PURPLE SAPPHIRE AND DIAMONDS - ALL RINGS
BEA RING WITH ROSE CUT PURPLE SAPPHIRE AND DIAMONDS - ALL RINGS

BEA RING WITH ROSE CUT PURPLE SAPPHIRE AND DIAMONDS

$2,690.00
LAVENDER SPINEL & DIAMOND RING -
 
LAVENDER SPINEL & DIAMOND RING -
LAVENDER SPINEL & DIAMOND RING -
Sold Out - Request to Order

LAVENDER SPINEL & DIAMOND RING

$6,250.00
BLOSSOM AQUAMARINE AND DIAMOND RING IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS
 
BLOSSOM AQUAMARINE AND DIAMOND RING IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS
BLOSSOM AQUAMARINE AND DIAMOND RING IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS

BLOSSOM AQUAMARINE AND DIAMOND RING IN PLATINUM

$3,625.00
MEADOW RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH AQUAMARINE - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS
 
MEADOW RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH AQUAMARINE - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS
MEADOW RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH AQUAMARINE - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS
MEADOW RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH AQUAMARINE - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS

MEADOW RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH AQUAMARINE

$3,250.00
MARQUISE EMERALD & DIAMOND BAND IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS
 
MARQUISE EMERALD & DIAMOND BAND IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS
MARQUISE EMERALD & DIAMOND BAND IN PLATINUM - ALL RINGS
Sold Out - Request to Order

MARQUISE EMERALD & DIAMOND BAND IN PLATINUM

$2,510.00
BLUE TOPAZ MARQUISE BAND IN WHITE GOLD - ALL RINGS
 
BLUE TOPAZ MARQUISE BAND IN WHITE GOLD - ALL RINGS
BLUE TOPAZ MARQUISE BAND IN WHITE GOLD - ALL RINGS
BLUE TOPAZ MARQUISE BAND IN WHITE GOLD - ALL RINGS
Sale

BLUE TOPAZ MARQUISE BAND IN WHITE GOLD

$990.00 $1,650.00
TANZANITE MARQUISE BAND IN YELLOW GOLD - ALL RINGS
 
TANZANITE MARQUISE BAND IN YELLOW GOLD - ALL RINGS
TANZANITE MARQUISE BAND IN YELLOW GOLD - ALL RINGS
TANZANITE MARQUISE BAND IN YELLOW GOLD - ALL RINGS
Sold Out - Request to Order

TANZANITE MARQUISE BAND IN YELLOW GOLD

$1,056.00 $1,760.00
BELLA PERIWINKLE BLUE SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
 
BELLA PERIWINKLE BLUE SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
BELLA PERIWINKLE BLUE SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
BELLA PERIWINKLE BLUE SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
Sold Out - Request to Order

BELLA PERIWINKLE BLUE SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING

$3,150.00
BELLA MORGANITE ENGAGEMENT RING IN ROSE GOLD - ALL RINGS
 
BELLA MORGANITE ENGAGEMENT RING IN ROSE GOLD - ALL RINGS
BELLA MORGANITE ENGAGEMENT RING IN ROSE GOLD - ALL RINGS
BELLA MORGANITE ENGAGEMENT RING IN ROSE GOLD - ALL RINGS

BELLA MORGANITE ENGAGEMENT RING IN ROSE GOLD

$1,960.00
SOPHIA RING WITH MORGANITE AND DIAMONDS IN ROSE GOLD - ALL RINGS
 
SOPHIA RING WITH MORGANITE AND DIAMONDS IN ROSE GOLD - ALL RINGS
SOPHIA RING WITH MORGANITE AND DIAMONDS IN ROSE GOLD - ALL RINGS
Sold Out - Request to Order

SOPHIA RING WITH MORGANITE AND DIAMONDS IN ROSE GOLD

$4,240.00
TESSA RING IN YELLOW GOLD WITH AMETHYST - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS
 
TESSA RING IN YELLOW GOLD WITH AMETHYST - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS
TESSA RING IN YELLOW GOLD WITH AMETHYST - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS

TESSA RING IN YELLOW GOLD WITH AMETHYST

$1,470.00
SYDNEY RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH BLUE SAPPHIRE - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS
 
SYDNEY RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH BLUE SAPPHIRE - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS
SYDNEY RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH BLUE SAPPHIRE - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS
SYDNEY RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH BLUE SAPPHIRE - ANNIVERSARY & CELEBRATION RINGS
Sold Out - Request to Order

SYDNEY RING IN WHITE GOLD WITH BLUE SAPPHIRE

$5,095.00
MIA RING WITH RADIANT PINK SAPPHIRE & DIAMONDS - rings
 
MIA RING WITH RADIANT PINK SAPPHIRE & DIAMONDS - rings
MIA RING WITH RADIANT PINK SAPPHIRE & DIAMONDS - rings

MIA RING WITH RADIANT PINK SAPPHIRE & DIAMONDS

$8,060.00
GLORIA SAPPHIRE AND DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
 
GLORIA SAPPHIRE AND DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
GLORIA SAPPHIRE AND DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
Sale

GLORIA SAPPHIRE AND DIAMOND ENGAGEMENT RING

$2,100.00 $3,500.00
TEARDROP BEZEL LAVENDER SAPPHIRE RING IN YELLOW GOLD - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
 
TEARDROP BEZEL LAVENDER SAPPHIRE RING IN YELLOW GOLD - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
TEARDROP BEZEL LAVENDER SAPPHIRE RING IN YELLOW GOLD - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS
TEARDROP BEZEL LAVENDER SAPPHIRE RING IN YELLOW GOLD - ALL ENGAGEMENT RINGS

TEARDROP BEZEL LAVENDER SAPPHIRE RING IN YELLOW GOLD

$2,355.00
MONROE PALE PINK SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL RINGS
 
MONROE PALE PINK SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL RINGS
MONROE PALE PINK SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING - ALL RINGS

MONROE PALE PINK SAPPHIRE ENGAGEMENT RING

$5,095.00

"While the jewellery that is in display is incredible, Penwarden really sparkles when it comes to collaborating with customers to rework existing heirlooms and jewels, breathing new life into pieces for their customers.

The team is personable, creative, collaborative and make any special project you bring to them a wonderful experience from start to finish. My family couldn't be happier with the collection we've created.

Thank you to Linda and the Penwarden Team!"

— C.M.

"My fiance and I recently designed my engagement ring with Marlene at Penwarden. Before we made the decision to choose Penwarden we visited several other jewelers ranging from boutique to big box. It was clear to me after a few other stops - Penwarden was the place if we wanted it to be personalized and special... Each time we consulted with Marlene she took time to listen to our ideas and then craft them into something beautiful - after all, she is the expert. We even had great coffee and even some champagne! It was never a pushy experience it was truly all about us.

Visit the store, talk to the team, you'll fall in love and make the right decision."

— M.M.

"Purchasing jewellery for the love of your life need not be an intimidating experience. Linda Penwarden is a gifted artist, a very talented jewellery designer and a lovely person.

Her dedication to craft, attention to the tiniest detail and unique sense of style make her collection of jewellery one of the most unique and one of a kind you will find anywhere at any price.

Her team of retail advisors are knowledgable, very helpful and extremely personable. A truly great shopping experience that you will not regret."

— R.C.

"I had a very good experience at Penwarden Fine Jewellery selecting and customizing an engagement ring for my fiance. The staff were helpful and happy to show me a wide range of options within my budget, including styles that I was not initially considering.

What drew me to this business over other jewelers in the City was Linda Penwarden's, designs and craftsmanship. Her signature lotus bezel setting is beautiful and unique and the ring looks beautiful from any viewing angle. This was not the case for many others that I looked at.

My fiance adores her ring, and so do I. I had a great experience overall and highly recommend this jeweler."

— J.O.

Visit the Boutique

Step into our Toronto boutique and discover the beauty of our collections in person.

Store Details

Personalized Shopping Just For You

Indulge in a one-on-one shopping experience tailored to your personal style and occasion.

Book Now

Handcrafted In-House

Ethically Sourced Materials

Generous Warranty